On the afternoon of December 4, 1872, the crew of the brigantine Dei Gratia spotted something strange on the horizon, roughly 400 miles east of the Azores. Another ship was out there, moving in a way no properly crewed vessel should, sails half set, drifting and yawing rather than holding a steady course, as though nobody at all was standing at her wheel.
Captain David Morehouse trained his glass on her and felt his stomach drop. He recognized the ship immediately. It was the Mary Celeste and Morehouse knew her captain personally.
Two Captains, One Dinner
Benjamin Spooner Briggs was 37 years old in the fall of 1872, and by every account that survives him, he was exactly the kind of man you'd want commanding a ship carrying your family. Devoutly religious, notably temperate, he had little interest in drinking, unusual for a sea captain of that era and widely respected among fellow seamen as fair, competent, and even-tempered. He'd handpicked his crew of seven himself, and by most accounts they were considered a strong, capable group, nothing like the troublemakers popular retellings of this story sometimes imagine.
Briggs wasn't planning to make the voyage alone. He brought his wife, Sarah, and their two-year-old daughter, Sophia, aboard as well, a decision that wasn't unusual for the period, when captains' wives often accompanied their husbands on long commercial voyages. The couple's older son stayed behind in the United States to continue his schooling.
In the days before departure, as the Mary Celeste sat docked in New York Harbor loading her cargo, Briggs crossed paths with an old acquaintance: David Morehouse, captain of the Dei Gratia, another merchant brigantine preparing for a similar Atlantic crossing. The two men, by multiple historical accounts, shared dinner together at New York's Astor House shortly before both ships set sail, a small, human detail that would matter enormously just weeks later.
Into the Atlantic
The Mary Celeste departed New York on November 7, 1872, bound for Genoa, Italy, carrying a cargo of 1,701 barrels of denatured alcohol - industrial-grade, undrinkable, and destined for use in Italian wine fortification and manufacturing. Ten people were aboard: Briggs, Sarah, Sophia, and the seven-man crew.
The Dei Gratia left the same New York port eight days later, on a broadly similar route toward the Mediterranean, carrying a cargo of petroleum. Morehouse had no reason to think much more about his friend's ship once both vessels were underway, the Atlantic was a big ocean, and two ships leaving over a week apart had no particular reason to cross paths again.
The Mary Celeste's own log shows a fairly ordinary crossing for the first few weeks, rough weather at points, as was typical for a November Atlantic voyage, but nothing that reads as an emergency. The last entry in the ship's logbook is dated November 25, roughly 8:00 in the morning, recording the ship's position as approximately six miles from Santa Maria Island in the Azores.
After that entry, there is no further record of anyone aboard the Mary Celeste ever writing another word.
A Ship Without a Crew
When the Dei Gratia finally drew close enough to make contact on December 4, repeated hails went unanswered. Morehouse sent his first mate, Oliver Deveau, along with another crewman, to row across and board her directly.
What they found made no sense at all. The Mary Celeste was completely deserted, not a single person anywhere aboard. Her only lifeboat, a smaller yawl normally stowed over the main hatch, was gone. Roughly three and a half feet of water had collected in the hold, and one of the ship's two bilge pumps had been partially disassembled, its parts left lying nearby. Both the forward hatch and the lazarette hatch toward the stern were uncovered and open. Below decks, charts had been tossed carelessly around the captain's quarters, and a sword lay sheathed in his cabin, though Deveau and his companion noted no obvious blood or visible signs of violence anywhere aboard.
And yet almost everything else looked completely untouched. The crew's personal belongings remained neatly stowed in their quarters, exactly where you'd expect them if their owners had simply stepped away rather than fled in panic. The ship's stores held enough food and water to last six months at sea, far more than would make sense to abandon voluntarily unless the crew expected to be picked up almost immediately. The cargo of alcohol was almost entirely intact; only nine of the 1,701 barrels later turned out to be empty. What was missing, notably, were the ship's papers and Captain Briggs's navigational instruments, his sextant and marine chronometer, the tools no experienced captain would ever willingly leave behind unless he intended to use them somewhere else.
The Mary Celeste, in other words, hadn't been ransacked, and she hadn't sunk. She'd simply been left - deliberately, it seemed, and in an apparent hurry, by ten people who had every reason to want to survive and no obvious reason to abandon a functioning ship in the middle of the Atlantic.
A Difficult Decision
Morehouse now faced a genuinely difficult choice. He was already short-handed for his own voyage, and splitting his crew to also sail a second, derelict ship into port meant real risk to both vessels. But maritime salvage law entitled him to a substantial reward for safely bringing an abandoned ship into harbor and the Mary Celeste, undamaged and still loaded with valuable cargo, represented a genuinely significant payday if he could pull it off.
He decided to try. Deveau and two sailors were assigned to crew the Mary Celeste, and both ships set out together for Gibraltar, arriving within days of each other. What awaited Morehouse there wasn't the reward he'd been hoping for. It was an official inquiry - one that would, before long, turn its suspicion directly onto him.
Read the Full Mary Celeste Investigation Series
Comments
Post a Comment